A personal view on music, all kinds of music.
Album: Grandine Il Vento
Label: Self released
Review: Diego Camargo
Renaissance was one of the first Prog bands I’ve heard. When I was 16/17 I’ve bought a
copy of Ashes Are Burning (1973) and I was in love with their music.
Now, years passed, I’ve enjoyed many of their albums and the band naturally came to an
Around 2010 the band made a comeback and since then they’re quite active. In 2010 they
released an EP with 3 new songs called The Mystic And The Muse (2011), they went on tour and played two of
their classic albums Turn Of The Cards (1974) and Scheherazade & Other Stories (1975),
after that they released a nice box with CD and DVD of this tour.
After all that they started to prepare a new album in 2012. To be able to do that they
successful crowdfunded a campaign to release their new album Grandine Il Vento (2013).
Unfortunately, after the album being recorded Michael Dunford (one of the original band
members) sadly passed away.
I must say that I was REALLY excited with the news of a new album by the band, their EP
was quite good so I could expect some really nice work.
I took my time to listen to the album, and last night I finally did? Well, what can I say, I am
disappointed after all.
Being a fan of the band I had so many high hopes on their new album, but it turned out not
that good as I was expecting.
First of all, from the original classic lineup there’s only Annie Haslam (vocals) that continues
to be a hell of a great singer, and Michael Dunford. Michael, unfortunatell is faded on this
album, his guitars are superb, but they barely REALLY appear on the album.
Second, the band isn’t that good. I mean, they were playing the bands back catalogue, but
creating? Not really!
Frank Pagano drums are there just to keep time, and that’s all. David J Keyes bass’ are?
not quite there. I know, he’s taking place of Jon Camp, an absolutely fantastic bass player.
But that’s no excuse!
Now, the worst part is taken by the keyboards. Renaissance’s music is Symphonic, always
been, so pianos and keyboards were a big part, especially pianos. Here the pianos are
really well put and well played by Rave Tesar, but the rest of the keyboards? a shame! I
cannot point my fingers to anyone really, cause the keyboards are credited to Rave and
Now really, what are those keyboards? There’s even a dance/club music kind of keyboards
on the opening track!
The music in Grandine Il Vento (2013) is not bad, in fact there’s many great moments, but
the overall arrangements kill anything really. As I said, especially the keyboards.
And there’s some songs that? shouldn’t be here like ‘Waterfall’ or ‘Porcelain’.
Unfortunately my high hopes were all felled, and I’m honestly sad about it.